Home > slashdot > Court Says Fair Use May Hold In Some RIAA Cases

Court Says Fair Use May Hold In Some RIAA Cases

December 9th, 2009 12:57 admin Leave a comment Go to comments

NewYorkCountryLawyer writes “In SONY BMG Music Entertainment v. Tenenbaum, the Boston RIAA case in which the defendant, represented by Charles Nesson of Harvard Law School, admitted liability at his trial, the Court has entered judgment in favor of the RIAA for the monetary award of $625,000 fixed by the jury. However, the Court left open the questions of whether the amount is excessive, and whether attorneys fees and/or sanctions should be awarded, and has scheduled further briefing of those issues. The Court granted the RIAA much, but not all, of the injunctive relief it rquested. In an unusual step, the Court issued a 38-page decision (PDF) explaining in some detail the Court’s views of the Fair Use defense in the context of cases like this, and indicating that there are some factual scenarios — not applicable in this particular case — in which it might have concluded that the claims were barred by Fair Use. E.g. it declined to rule out the possibility that creation of mp3 files exclusively for space-shifting purposes from audio CDs a defendant had previously purchased might constitute fair use.”

Source: Court Says Fair Use May Hold In Some RIAA Cases

Related Articles:

  1. RIAA Confusion In Tenenbaum & Thomas Cases?
  2. “Innocent Infringement” Defense May Reach Supreme Court
  3. Constitutionality of RIAA Damages Challenged
  4. RIAA Lobbyist Becomes Federal Judge, Rules On File-Sharing Cases
  5. Court Grants RIAA Summary Judgment Motions vs. Limewire
blog comments powered by Disqus